Top Search Engine Spots via Social Network Sites
2.0 Market Attraction StrategiesThere’s a huge rush on - from marketers around the globe - to market their products and services (or increase their search engine position) by posting content and creating profiles on multiple Web 2.0 properties.
This is one way a very smart internet marketing trainer is teaching others to domninate the search engine listings for their select keywords.
It’s a great idea, but is it a viable long-term solution to increasing brand awareness and building business value? Or is it a short term solution to (hopefully) some fast cash?
Surfers Spending More Hours on Web 2.0 - Less on Search
Before you run off creating multiple accounts on multiple Web 2.0 properties and posting your proprietary content there in an attempt to dominate the top 10 results in google, consider the research - excerpted from Strategic Social Marketing, (2007) below.
Question: Is your target market, in fact, still using the search engines?
The Online Publishers Association Internet Activity Index (2007), classifies and documents web surfer activity. At the time of writing, here is the average time surfers gave to each of these four activities:
1. Searching for information 5%
2. Commerce (shopping) 16.1%
3. Content (news, information, and entertainment) 45.5%
4. Communications (engaging in communication) 33.7%
Don’t miss the way OPAI describes these activities or you’ll find yourself thinking that your one way content delivery is still a viable way to attract and hold eyeballs on your website…
Content – Sites that provide news, information and entertainment (given the entertainment qualification of this category and based on comScore’s research above, most of this percentage could in fact be Web 2.0).
Communications – Sites that facilitate the exchange of thoughts, messages, or information directly between individuals or groups of individuals. (definitely web 2.0)
Commerce - Sites that are designed for shopping online. (some of both)
Search - Sites that provide prioritized results based on user-generated requests.
Stability of Web 2.0 Properties
Question: How much time do you have to lose? How much money do you have to spend on outsourcing the work?
Social networking websites are still a relatively new business model. As such many start-ups haven’t quite figured out their income source and how to pay the bandwidth bills.
Consider one hot web property (bolt.com) that went offline just this month. Bolt had it made with a member base of 4,000,000 and over 14,000,000 unique visitors/month. Yet on August 14 an Assignment for the Benefit of Creditors was filed and Bolt is no longer accessible for users, search engines, or the 14 million unique visitors. If you were posting to Bolt previous, your work would be for naught today.
Social networking websites don’t need to shut down for your efforts to be wasted. Changes in a site’s Terms of Service as well as over zealous ‘reporting’ on your content could get your user account taken away from you. If this happens all your content and time invested is lost.
Conclusion
I am not stating that what others are teaching is wrong, or bad. I just want you to be sure it is right for you and your business model.
There may be better ways to spend your time than attempting to captivate the search engine listings (especially when ’search’ is such a small part of how your target market uses the web). There may be better ways to post content to a social networking site (i.e. automated RSS feed integration) than risking the loss of content due to site closures and account suspensions.
I know initial research can be drab, but in the end it serves you well. Take your time to devise a smart strategy for your online marketing and stay informed of both surfing trends and the viability of each business practice you partake in.

Laura Childs



October 19th, 2007 at 9:00 am
Very good info. I was pondering this myself.Please keep providing more content like this because people need to know this.
October 19th, 2007 at 9:52 am
As always, very informative and extremely helpful. You just helped me make a decision on adjusting my web marketing strategy. Now I have a better handle on where to spend time. You keep writing them and I’ll keep reading them! Many thanks for your hard work.
October 19th, 2007 at 10:14 am
Always on point.
It is never wise to put all your eggs in one basket.
October 19th, 2007 at 10:32 am
Very good info. Thanks
October 19th, 2007 at 10:34 am
try looking at this page in firefox - it sucks on the right hand side of the page
October 19th, 2007 at 10:59 am
I’m using Firefox. Everything looking fine on my end.
October 19th, 2007 at 11:01 am
Hi John, thanks for that!
When I originally launched this site I fussed with the design and checked it in FireFox. However it slipped through the cracks when I added new items to the sidebar last week, so thanks for bringing it to my attenetion.
I’m still only seeing (across multiple sites and markets) less than 20% of my readers are FireFox browsers.
Thanks again, Laura
October 19th, 2007 at 11:09 am
Good information, Laura, even if it still feels sort of cloudy. I trust you’re on the cutting edge and are doing the research. I’ve just ordered Strategic Social Marketing and will see where that takes me. I know social networking as I’ve learned so far, has not worked for me. Hopefully that will change.
P.S. I use firefox, and some of your pages are off on the right side bar, and some look perfect.
October 19th, 2007 at 11:39 am
Dear Deb, thanks for your note and your trust on order.
I wrote the post thinking I was brilliant for putting all the cards on the table. I agree with you whole-heartedly that it feels ‘cloudy’.
In one sense I’m teaching people to work with Web 2.0 and in another, to ‘beware’ if their focus is on business building for the long term.
So let’s see if I can clear this up…
a) work smart and within the boundaries of Web 2.0 by finding the niche sites your target market populate.
b) understand ‘tags’ explicitly and document your efforts.
c) where ever possible populate your profile and networking content via your website/blog’s RSS feed.
d) prioritize your website’s needs by studying surfer trends. (For instance you may have top ranks in google for a choice keyword or phrase but see very little return for those top ranks. Know where your buyer is ’searching’, ‘clicking from’, and spending time. It may not be google after all.)
e) watch your site stats.
The point, I suppose, is that every market is different, every business’ current mandate varied; and as such a strategic plan of action is required.
Laura
October 19th, 2007 at 12:22 pm
Great Information!!
October 20th, 2007 at 6:20 am
Hooray! At last someone is asking where all the “traffic” went from the big search engines.
I have front page results on all the main SEs but have watch a tremendous decline in visitors over the last two years. Almost every technique that produced measurable results in recent years now produces a small confusing shift in position only to vanish in a few week.
Most so called advice from SEO sources sound more and more like dinosaurs roaming around waiting for the food to run out!
The way forward in 2.0 may not yet be clear but the shift away from the SEs certainly is.
Looking forward to your thoughts Laura.
October 22nd, 2007 at 5:00 am
Laura
You’re quite right. A “one-trick pony” is a “one-trick pony” whatever you choose to call it.
Some of my clients tell me that they “only cold call” for business. Others tell me that they “never cold call”. Both are equally wrong!
Any balanced business growth plan, whether online or off, needs multiple routes to market. If one drops off then you have another one, and another, and another…
Using social sites is a viable way of building business at the moment, whether for the short term or the long, but it should be only one-part of your whole route to market.
October 26th, 2007 at 8:29 pm
Hi there - great article and I completely agree with you. I have always been a huge Google person, but I find myself first checking out de.licio.us because I find the coolest things there. I just wrote an article on increasing your traffic from social bookmarking / networking sites and I think it has some good tips for webmasters looking for a boost in traffic.
Thanks for the great article.
Rachel